Master Of Puppets vs. Ride The Lightning

Here we go... MOP wins for sure.

Battery vs. Fight Fire With Fire
Battery easy. 1/0
Master Of Puppets vs. Ride The Lightning
Master easy. 2/0
The Thing That Should Not Be vs. For Whom The Bell Tolls
I love both, but TTTSNB is so underrated. 3/0
Welcome Home (Sanitarium) vs. Fade To Black
UGHHHHHHHHHHHHHH. Tie. 4/1
Disposable Heroes vs. Trapped Under Ice
Trapped is so underrated and amazing. 4/2
Leper Messiah vs. Escape
LM easy. 5/2
Orion vs. The Call Of Ktulu
I'm going TCOK. 5/3
Damage Inc. vs. Creeping Death
DI is amazing but it can't compare to the monster that is CD. 5/4.

I know I changed the order of RTL slightly, I felt like the instrumentals needed to go against each other.
Master wins! By less than I expected actually. I still feel like MOP is much further ahead of RTL though.

1. Battery
2. Master of Puppets
3. For Whom the Bell Tolls
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Leper Messiah
7. Orion
8. Creeping Death

I did get the 6/2 you were predicting... and I like Ride more than you! I guess this shows it's slightly dependent on album order... but Metallica does tend to order their albums similarly

StevenCressler wrote:1. Battery
2. Master of Puppets
3. For Whom the Bell Tolls
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Lepetr Messiah
7. Orion
8. Creeping Death

I did get the 6/2 you were predicting... and I like Ride more than you! I guess this shows it's slightly dependent on album order... but Metallica does tend to order their albums similarly

Yep! Lepetr Messiah, I'm going to start calling it that. Lep-e-ter

I also feel like production has something to do with it.

Battery
Master of Puppets
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home
Trapped Under Ice
Leper Messiah
Orion
Creeping Death

WildWorld wrote:Battery
Master of Puppets
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home
Trapped Under Ice
Leper Messiah
Orion
Creeping Death

Almost exactly the same, the only difference is Trapped. I love Trapped, but I don't think it can beat Heroes.

StevenCressler wrote:

WildWorld wrote:Battery
Master of Puppets
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home
Trapped Under Ice
Leper Messiah
Orion
Creeping Death

Almost exactly the same, the only difference is Trapped. I love Trapped, but I don't think it can beat Heroes.

Heroes could easily fit on AJFA

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

WildWorld wrote:Battery
Master of Puppets
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Welcome Home
Trapped Under Ice
Leper Messiah
Orion
Creeping Death

Almost exactly the same, the only difference is Trapped. I love Trapped, but I don't think it can beat Heroes.

Heroes could easily fit on AJFA

I agree... and AJFA is my #1 all-time album, so...

But Trapped's soloing and riffing...

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:But Trapped's soloing and riffing...

The main riff is amazing, I'll say that. I'm sure the solo is great but solos tend to blend together for me

Battery over Fire
Tie between MoP and Ride - it's simple but effective
FWTBT is just too ubiquitous, I'll take TTTSNB
Sanitarium vs. Fade, tough but Sanitarium. No wait, Fade's bridge riff is iconic. I'm going tie.
DH vs. Trapped, Trapped is one of my favorite deeper tracks
LM vs Escape, Escape is a little more listener friendly not big on Leper's main riff
Orion over Call, Call's intro is so repetitive I can't listen to it anymore
Creeping Death over Damage, CD is a top twenty metal song

3-3 tie
Overall, I like Ride's production better, so that breaks the tie.  I guess.
I can't believe I got sucked into. Now I feel like a tool.

Superjuice wrote:Battery over Fire
Tie between MoP and Ride - it's simple but effective
FWTBT is just too ubiquitous, I'll take TTTSNB
Sanitarium vs. Fade, tough but Sanitarium. No wait, Fade's bridge riff is iconic. I'm going tie.
DH vs. Trapped, Trapped is one of my favorite deeper tracks
LM vs Escape, Escape is a little more listener friendly not big on Leper's main riff
Orion over Call, Call's intro is so repetitive I can't listen to it anymore
Creeping Death over Damage, CD is a top twenty metal song

3-3 tie
Overall, I like Ride's production better, so that breaks the tie.  I guess.
I can't believe I got sucked into. Now I feel like a tool.

Uh...