Album Battle! ...And Justice For All vs. Master Of Puppets - Metallica

Here we go. Try to rank the songs by music and lyrics not production please. I know AJFA has 9 and MOP has 8, I'm removing Shortest Straw but it would win, I love that song.

Battery vs. Blackened
This is actually really hard... Tie. 1/1
Master Of Puppets vs. ...And Justice For All
UGHHH, STILL HARD. But c'mon it's Puppets. 2/1
The Thing That Should Not Be vs. Eye Of The Beholder
Two underrated tracks... I'm going TTTSNB, their first drop d song. 3/1
Welcome Home (Sanitarium) vs. One
This is literally impossible. Tie 4/2
Disposable Heroes vs. Harvester Of Sorrow
This is hard because DH could fit perfectly on AJFA imo. Tie 5/3
Leper Messiah vs. The Frayed Ends Of Sanity
MY FAVORITE TRACKS FROM EACH ALBUM UGHHH. Both SUPER underrated. I'm going Sanity (LM has better lyrics though). 5/4
Orion vs. To Live Is To Die
The instrumentals. Yeah it's TLITD not hard imo. (O is still awesome). 5/5
Damage Inc. vs. Dyers Eve
Both so thrashy and heavy. I think Dyers Eve by a hair. 5/6

If you do Shortest Straw vs. DH instead of HOS it would be 5/7
...And Justice For All wins!

You should have done Master vs Ride, both have 8 tracks
1. Blackened, but it could go either way
2. Master of Puppets
3. Eye of the Beholder
4. One (these are their two best songs imo lol)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Frayed Ends of Sanity
7. Orion
8. Dyers Eve

And Heroes would still win over straw
3/5

StevenCressler wrote:You should have done Master vs Ride, both have 8 tracks
1. Blackened, but it could go either way
2. Master of Puppets
3. Eye of the Beholder
4. One (these are their two best songs imo lol)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Frayed Ends of Sanity
7. Orion
8. Dyers Eve

And Heroes would still win over straw
3/5

I would've been like 6/2 MoP

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:You should have done Master vs Ride, both have 8 tracks
1. Blackened, but it could go either way
2. Master of Puppets
3. Eye of the Beholder
4. One (these are their two best songs imo lol)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Frayed Ends of Sanity
7. Orion
8. Dyers Eve

And Heroes would still win over straw
3/5

I would've been like 6/2 MoP

That's true, I forgot you put Ride lower than most people... though I would also probably be similar because most Ride songs are amazing songs, but not as good as the respective Master songs

StevenCressler wrote:

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:You should have done Master vs Ride, both have 8 tracks
1. Blackened, but it could go either way
2. Master of Puppets
3. Eye of the Beholder
4. One (these are their two best songs imo lol)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Frayed Ends of Sanity
7. Orion
8. Dyers Eve

And Heroes would still win over straw
3/5

I would've been like 6/2 MoP

That's true, I forgot you put Ride lower than most people... though I would also probably be similar because most Ride songs are amazing songs, but not as good as the respective Master songs

I posted MOP vs. RTL... I was surprised with what happened...

Why is Metallica in this section?

Pro-Zak wrote:Why is Metallica in this section?

Did I put it in Christian Metal? That was a mistake lol.

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

Pro-Zak wrote:Why is Metallica in this section?

Did I put it in Christian Metal? That was a mistake lol.

Kerrick, your time to shine lol.