Re: Favorite third thrash album?

by TZ75 Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:32 am

That’s why Tourniquet were so great! Ted knew how to combine his avant-garde tendencies with a catchy hook. POD is the best example of that!

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:42 am

TZ75 wrote:That’s why Tourniquet were so great! Ted knew how to combine his avant-garde tendencies with a catchy hook. POD is the best example of that!

Deleted.

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:50 am

Raegoul wrote:
Dustofyears wrote:
Pethead wrote:As good as POD is, I'm surprised there are no votes for Dimensions yet. I'd put that in second place, personally.
Oooo, Dimensions... forgot about that... Pathogenic of course is great... Can I pick two- Dimensions and Destruction comes...
I have listened to Believer Dimensions dozens of times these past weeks and it‘s starting to finally grow on me. Trilogy is a masterpiece. However, I still like Extraction and Sanity more, they are just more accessible, may I use the word catchy? Dimensions is more demanding and you have to spend time with it, undoubtedly a great album but it feels somehow unfinished/incoherent with six songs of a similar style and then the monolithic trilogy which is a thing of it‘s own. Maybe the should have put out the Trilogy as an EP and written two or three mor „regular“ songs for to go with the other six for the third album. Just rambling, thx for reading.

Deleted.

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 6:59 am

Raegoul wrote:
Dustofyears wrote:
Pethead wrote:As good as POD is, I'm surprised there are no votes for Dimensions yet. I'd put that in second place, personally.
Oooo, Dimensions... forgot about that... Pathogenic of course is great... Can I pick two- Dimensions and Destruction comes...
I have listened to Believer Dimensions dozens of times these past weeks and it‘s starting to finally grow on me. Trilogy is a masterpiece. However, I still like Extraction and Sanity more, they are just more accessible, may I use the word catchy? Dimensions is more demanding and you have to spend time with it, undoubtedly a great album but it feels somehow unfinished/incoherent with six songs of a similar style and then the monolithic trilogy which is a thing of it‘s own. Maybe the should have put out the Trilogy as an EP and written two or three mor „regular“ songs for to go with the other six for the third album. Just rambling, thx for eading.

Deleted

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 7:36 am

Deleted.

by MagnusPrime Sun Jan 15, 2023 9:11 am

Dustofyears wrote:

Deleted.
That giy bacjh or whatever knoes hwt hes talkin butb. Cherrs

Saved.
Can we get a Klingon interpreter?

drunken

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 11:11 am

MagnusPrime wrote:
Dustofyears wrote:

Deleted.
That giy bacjh or whatever knoes hwt hes talkin butb. Cherrs

Saved.
Can we get a Klingon interpreter?

Okay.. last deleted. Takes it easy guys. Catch ya up in the clouds some day, haha.

by TZ75 Sun Jan 15, 2023 5:41 pm

You know you don’t need to announce that you deleted if you come back soon after you posted and hit the little box with the x in it.

It only works until someone else writes a response.

by Dustofyears Sun Jan 15, 2023 8:34 pm

TZ75 wrote:You know you don’t need to announce that you deleted if you come back soon after you posted and hit the little box with the x in it.

It only works until someone else writes a response.

Ah didn't know that. Thank you. Went on a drunk online rampage. Apologies all. Lesson- don't drink and type!

by TZ75 Sun Jan 15, 2023 11:31 pm

Dustofyears wrote:
TZ75 wrote:You know you don’t need to announce that you deleted if you come back soon after you posted and hit the little box with the x in it.

It only works until someone else writes a response.
Ah didn't know that. Thank you. Went on a drunk online rampage. Apologies all. Lesson- don't drink and type!

Yeah I figured you had a few drinks. Luckily you weren’t one of the combative types (at least not towards me). Haha

by CrimsonWarrior Mon Jan 16, 2023 12:18 am

POD for sure. Just a fantastic adventure from start to finish.

by Dustofyears Tue Jan 17, 2023 12:15 am

TZ75 wrote:
Dustofyears wrote:
TZ75 wrote:You know you don’t need to announce that you deleted if you come back soon after you posted and hit the little box with the x in it.

It only works until someone else writes a response.
Ah didn't know that. Thank you. Went on a drunk online rampage. Apologies all. Lesson- don't drink and type!

Yeah I figured you had a few drinks. Luckily you weren’t one of the combative types (at least not towards me). Haha

That's good. I think most of it was incoherent jibberish, but I could type DELETED just fine, lol.

by Dustofyears Tue Jan 17, 2023 12:25 am

MagnusPrime wrote:
Dustofyears wrote:

Deleted.
That giy bacjh or whatever knoes hwt hes talkin butb. Cherrs

Saved.
Can we get a Klingon interpreter?

You Saved some of my drunken ramblings... Favorite third thrash album? - Page 2 1f602

by bgsully Wed Jan 18, 2023 11:13 pm

Torn between Pathogenic and Dimensions...

I guess I'll go with Dimensions

by StevenCressler Sun Dec 17, 2023 5:02 pm

Tbh, I'll go with What a Joke. I think I rated several songs on it too high, and several on POD too low, so I'm sure that will change after a rescore (and I don't count the joke tracks), but for now it's WaJ

by seth Sun Dec 17, 2023 5:34 pm

Very unpopular opinion apparently, but I’m actually not too big a fan of POD, with the exception of a couple of songs. Way better than the two albums to follow, but the transition from more melodic vocals of the previous albums (especially StB) to mostly shouting/barking was a move in the wrong direction imo

by TZ75 Sun Dec 17, 2023 6:29 pm

Tourniquet - POD
Deliverance - What A Joke
Vengeance Rising - Destruction Comes

by TZ75 Sun Dec 17, 2023 6:30 pm

It’s too bad many bands quit after two or three albums…

by Black Rider Sun Dec 17, 2023 6:48 pm

seth wrote:Very unpopular opinion apparently, but I’m actually not too big a fan of POD, with the exception of a couple of songs. Way better than the two albums to follow, but the transition from more melodic vocals of the previous albums (especially StB) to mostly shouting/barking was a move in the wrong direction imo

Stb sounds like a cat on helium half the time.

by StevenCressler Sun Dec 17, 2023 6:49 pm

seth wrote:Very unpopular opinion apparently, but I’m actually not too big a fan of POD, with the exception of a couple of songs. Way better than the two albums to follow, but the transition from more melodic vocals of the previous albums (especially StB) to mostly shouting/barking was a move in the wrong direction imo

Even though I love it, I agree that it's overrated. I prefer MVoaTR and AB

by Pethead Sun Dec 17, 2023 7:09 pm

POD is the greatest metal album in Christian music, you crazy people.

by StevenCressler Sun Dec 17, 2023 7:23 pm

Black Rider wrote:
seth wrote:Very unpopular opinion apparently, but I’m actually not too big a fan of POD, with the exception of a couple of songs. Way better than the two albums to follow, but the transition from more melodic vocals of the previous albums (especially StB) to mostly shouting/barking was a move in the wrong direction imo
Stb sounds like a cat on helium half the time.

Nah, the falsetto on that album is great. I normally wouldn't like stuff like that, but I think it sounds really good. Actually, reading this made me decide to put on Ready or Not lol

by Black Rider Sun Dec 17, 2023 7:39 pm

Pethead wrote:POD is the greatest metal album in Christian music, you crazy people.

This is Canon.

by Superjuice Mon Dec 18, 2023 12:40 pm

StevenCressler wrote:
Black Rider wrote:
seth wrote:Very unpopular opinion apparently, but I’m actually not too big a fan of POD, with the exception of a couple of songs. Way better than the two albums to follow, but the transition from more melodic vocals of the previous albums (especially StB) to mostly shouting/barking was a move in the wrong direction imo
Stb sounds like a cat on helium half the time.
Nah, the falsetto on that album is great. I normally wouldn't like stuff like that, but I think it sounds really good. Actually, reading this made me decide to put on Ready or Not lol

I wonder why they went cold turkey on the falsetto vocals? It would have been an even better album had they just mixed it in some like Sacred Warrior's "The Flood." Ted must've just bent the knee to the current trends where old-school metal just wasn't cool anymore. I know he laid out some rules on POD like they were to avoid thrash cliche's like 'cut time' (think of the Master of Puppets chorus).

by Pethead Mon Dec 18, 2023 1:06 pm

From what I understand, the response to the vocals on StB was mixed. Then Guy left during POD at least in part because the music was getting too heavy for his tastes. At least I believe Guy said that was one of the reasons in an interview I read a few years ago.

I don’t think it had to do with trend-hopping. It’s not as if PS and POD are just aping what was currently popular. It’s also interesting to note that Guy doesn’t use any falsetto on Polarized.

by Sponsored content