John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
4 posters
Page 1 of 1
John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
I actually rather enjoyed this, but the question I want to ask... would you consider this Christian music?
Warning: lolprofanity
Warning: lolprofanity
ThomasEversole- Holy Unblack Knight
- Posts : 2088
Join date : 2013-03-19
Age : 43
Re: John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
I listened to exactly 36 seconds of that before I had to stop (take note of his profanity warning people).
I know nothing about John R. Butler or the rest of the song. Is it sung sincerely or is that sarcasm or parody? The answer goes a long way to my answer.
My two cents on "Is ________ a Christian band?" questions is that it is a continuum. There are ministry-oriented bands, there are Christians-in-a-band, there are some-members-are-Christians, there are bands were the singer who writes the songs is a Christian so the lyrics are Christian-ish (or at least clean) but the rest of the band aren't Christians. Depending on the context I could call many things Christian or not.
I personally have standards in the music I can buy so the threads on "Is ________ Christian?" matter to me. Dogmatic yes, no, or who cares answers don't do the gray area bands justice.
Personally I will never buy John R. Butler music for the profanity, even IF I liked the music (I don't) or IF it is sung sincerely.
I know nothing about John R. Butler or the rest of the song. Is it sung sincerely or is that sarcasm or parody? The answer goes a long way to my answer.
My two cents on "Is ________ a Christian band?" questions is that it is a continuum. There are ministry-oriented bands, there are Christians-in-a-band, there are some-members-are-Christians, there are bands were the singer who writes the songs is a Christian so the lyrics are Christian-ish (or at least clean) but the rest of the band aren't Christians. Depending on the context I could call many things Christian or not.
I personally have standards in the music I can buy so the threads on "Is ________ Christian?" matter to me. Dogmatic yes, no, or who cares answers don't do the gray area bands justice.
Personally I will never buy John R. Butler music for the profanity, even IF I liked the music (I don't) or IF it is sung sincerely.
eatbugs- Holy Unblack Knight
- Posts : 2185
Join date : 2012-08-28
Location : Michigan
Re: John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
I like you criteria regarding defining Christian music. I personally think listener interpretation can easily trump artist intentions though.
I think I'm more intrigued at recoiling from words enough to stop the video. ...but I'm not one to hold as much weight to cursing. Ever watch a DVD that has French audio? Depending on the movie, it might not sound much different than this John R Butler's track.
It's funny to me how society has planted within us to have emotional responses to these sounds...
I think I'm more intrigued at recoiling from words enough to stop the video. ...but I'm not one to hold as much weight to cursing. Ever watch a DVD that has French audio? Depending on the movie, it might not sound much different than this John R Butler's track.
It's funny to me how society has planted within us to have emotional responses to these sounds...
ThomasEversole- Holy Unblack Knight
- Posts : 2088
Join date : 2013-03-19
Age : 43
Re: John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
If you check out his website, Butler seems to be a lot more about comedy than about truly singing for the Lord. In that context, this just comes off as disrespectful, in poor taste, and dare I say sacrilegious.
This just reminds me of a bluegrass Sam Kinison.
This just reminds me of a bluegrass Sam Kinison.
Re: John R Butler's "Hand of the Almighty"
I won't listen to because of the profanity warning. If one has to resort to profanity in their lyrics then they aren't much of a lyricist in my opinion.
Similar topics
» Ordo Aurum (Golden Order of the Almighty)
» NEW ALBUM. Renascent - Praise of the Lord God Almighty
» [Review] Renascent - Praise of the Lord God Almighty
» Hand of Fire update
» Renascent - Praise Of The Lord God Almighty [remixed & remastered CD]
» NEW ALBUM. Renascent - Praise of the Lord God Almighty
» [Review] Renascent - Praise of the Lord God Almighty
» Hand of Fire update
» Renascent - Praise Of The Lord God Almighty [remixed & remastered CD]
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|