Every Star Trek TOS episode ranked

To avoid clogging the show thread, I'll post this here

Tier 1: Not Good
79. And the Children Shall Lead
Tier 3: Okay
78. Mudd's Women
77. The Way to Eden
76. The Alternative Factor
Tier 4: Decent
75. Elaan of Troyius
74. The Paradise Syndrome
73. Miri
72. Who Mourns for Adonais?
71. The Mark of Gideon
70. The Conscience of the King
69. Wink of an Eye
68. The Deadly Years
67. Dagger of the Mind
Tier 5: Good
66. The Lights of Zetar
65. Catspaw
64. The Empath
63. Spock's Brain
62. Wolf in the Fold
61. The Omega Glory
60. Plato's Stepchildren
59. The Return of the Archons
58. Charlie X
57. For The World Is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky
56. The Galileo Seven
55. Assignment: Earth
54. The Cloud Minders
53. Court Martial
52. The Changeling
51. Operation -- Annihilate!
50. The Squire of Gothos
49. Requiem for Methuselah
48. Obsession
47. That Which Survives
46. Let That Be Your Last Battlefied
45. I, Mudd
44. Tommorrow is Yesterday
43. Patterns of Force
42. Errand of Mercy
41. The Man Trap
40. The Naked Time
39. The Corbomite Manuever
38. What Are Little Girls Made Of?
37. Bread and Circus
36. Turnabout Intruder
35. The Enemy Within
34. The Savage Curtain
33. The Doomsday Machine
32. A Piece of the Action
31. The Gamesters of Triskelion
30. Metamorphosis
29. A Private Little War
28. Where No Man Has Gone Before
27. Friday's Child
26. The Immunity Syndrome
25. The Tholian Web
24. Whom Gods Destroy
23. Arena
22. By Any Other Name
21. The Menagerie, Part 1
20. The Apple
19. Spectre of the Gun
18. Journey to Babel
17. The Trouble With Tribbles
16. Is There In Truth No Beauty?
15. Shore Leave
Tier 6: Really Good
14. Balance of Terror
13. Space Seed
12. The Enterprise Incident
11. The Ultimate Computer
10. The Menagerie, Part 2
9. All Our Yesterdays
8. The Devil in the Dark
7. This Side of Paradise
6. Day of the Dove
5. Amok Time
Tier 7: Very good
4. A Taste of Armageddon
3. The City on the Edge of Forever
2. Return to Tommorrow
1. Mirror, Mirror

Spock’s Brain in “good?” Interesting.

I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Pethead wrote:Spock’s Brain in “good?” Interesting.

Objectively it doesn't belong there, but it's a funny episode with some great sets (specifically the surface of the planet) and some good action.

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

You might be a nerd if...

You can recall every Star Trek plot just by looking at the title of the episode.

Superjuice wrote:You might be a nerd if...

You can recall every Star Trek plot just by looking at the title of the episode.

To be fair, Trek had some great titles.

Superjuice wrote:You might be a nerd if...

You can recall every Star Trek plot just by looking at the title of the episode.

I've known I'm a nerd for a while lol

I only remember a few by the title.   My cousins were big Trekkies and used to go to Star Trek conventions.  
I would tag along to hunt for comic books and other sci-fi previews.  
I have a few Star Trek crew autographs and some pictures of Shatner, Doohan, and Koenig.

Star Trek isn't good enough to warrant this type of deliberations...

Sevenoneself wrote:Star Trek isn't good enough to warrant this type of deliberations...

Go watch City on the Edge of Forever

Seen 'em all. I enjoy them as much as the next guy, but not near as much as you!!

Sevenoneself wrote:Seen 'em all. I enjoy them as much as the next guy, but not near as much as you!!

Okay lol.
I think you've rejoined the forum after my last ranking, but I've also ranked every song from several bands... most people here expect this kind of nerdiness from me

StevenCressler wrote:

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

Arena the one where they are on Vulcan an Spock has to fight Jim over some vulcan girl, right? Fascinating!

Raegoul wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

Arena the one where they are on Vulcan an Spock has to fight Jim over some vulcan girl, right? Fascinating!

That's Amok Time. Arena is the one where Kirk has to fight a the goofy-looking lizard man

Sevenoneself wrote:Star Trek isn't good enough to warrant this type of deliberations...

Star Trek>The Gift of Music

^^ LOL…priceless.

Sevenoneself wrote:Star Trek isn't good enough to warrant this type of deliberations...

Thumbs down!!!

Raegoul wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

Arena the one where they are on Vulcan an Spock has to fight Jim over some vulcan girl, right? Fascinating!

Arena is the Gorn battle.  Amok Time is the Spock vs. Kirk match.

BaleMaster wrote:

Raegoul wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

Arena the one where they are on Vulcan an Spock has to fight Jim over some vulcan girl, right? Fascinating!

Arena is the Gorn battle.  Amok Time is the Spock vs. Kirk match.

Two of my favorites.  Also:

Devil in the Dark 
Space Seed

Sevenoneself wrote:Star Trek isn't good enough to warrant this type of deliberations...

Your statement is most illogical.  

scottmitchell74 wrote:

BaleMaster wrote:

Raegoul wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Constantine wrote:I remember "Charlie X" and "The Menagerie Parts 1 & 2 as being some of the creepiest ones.   I also liked "Arena" a lot.

Yeah they were creepy. Arena has some of the shows best action.

Arena the one where they are on Vulcan an Spock has to fight Jim over some vulcan girl, right? Fascinating!

Arena is the Gorn battle.  Amok Time is the Spock vs. Kirk match.

Two of my favorites.  Also:

Devil in the Dark 
Space Seed

I gotta say I never liked Space Seed.  I'm glad it was the "seed" that led to one of the greatest movies of all time: KHAAAAAAAAAAAN!!!!  However, I fail to find the appeal in the episode.  It's mostly Kirk and Mr. Rourke jabbering sitting at a table. Then it ends in a mono-e-mono in which Kirk overcomes a "genetically superior" human in hand to hand combat using some space prop.  Found it dull as a kid and disappointed as an adult that they didn't have a more clever solution.