Fav / Least Fav songs per album - Metallica

KEA:
fav - No Remorse
least - Anesthesia


RTL:
fav - Escape
least - (no weak tracks!)


MOP:
fav - Disposable Heroes
least - (no weak tracks!)


AJFA:
fav - The Shortest Straw
least - (no weak tracks!)


Metallica:
fav - Through The Never
least - Enter Sandman


Load:
fav - Bleeding Me
least - Poor Twisted Me 


Re-Load
fav - Where The Wild Things Are
least - Attitude


SA:
fav - Sweet Amber
least - (most of the rest)


DM:
fav - All Nightmare Long
least - Suicide & Redemption


HTSD:
fav - Spit Out The Bone
least - Murder One

KeA:
Fav: The Four Horsemen
Least: Anesthesia 

RtL:
Fav: Creeping Death
Least: The Call of Kthulu 

MoP:
Fav: Battery 
Least: Leper Messiah

AJfA:
Fav: The Shortest Straw
Least: To Live Is to Die

TBA:
Fav: Don’t Tread on Me
Least: The God That Failed

Load:
Fav: King Nothing 
Least: unsure

ReLoad:
Unsure 

St. Anger
Fav: the moments of silence between the tracks
Least: the other moments

DM:
Fav: All Nightmare Long
Least: unsure

H…tSD:
Fav: Moth to Flame
Least: Murder One

Your St Anger fave and least.

Mustaine them all, uh, I mean, Kill 'em all

Fav: Four Horsemen

Least: Phantom Lord


Ride the Lightening


Fav: Call of Ktulu (Cause Lovecraft)

Least: They all excellent


Master Of Puppets

Fav: Thing that should not be (Cause Lovecraft)


Least: They all excellent.


Justice


Favorite: Harvester of sorrow

Least: They all excellent (my favorite by Metallica)


Black album


Favorite: Through the Never (that main riff is cool, and it just grooves

Least: Can't remember. Pretty excellent album all round



Load and reload had one good album if about half of each albums were combined. Some good songs on those albums, but haven't listened to them for long time.



That was end of the line for me and Metallica.

KEA
Fav-Seek and Destroy
Least-Phantom Lord

RTL
Fav-Creeping Death
Least-Call of Ktulu (no real bad songs on here though)

MOP
Fav-Title track
Least-Thing that should not be

Garage Days
Fav-Helpless
Least-The Small Hours

AJFA
Fav-Dyer's Eve
Least-Title track (of the first four Metallica LPs, this is also my least fav)

Black album
Fav-Holier Than Thou
Least-Nothing Else Matters

Load
Fav-King Nothing
Least-Wasting My Hate

Reload
Fav-Fuel
Least-Low Man's Lyric

Garage Inc
Fav-Whiskey in the Jar
Least-Loverman

St. Anger
Fav-St. Anger (though that's basically the best of a bad lot)
Least-My World

DM
Fav-My Apocolypse
Least-Unforgiven 3

HTSD
Fav-Atlas Rise
Least-Murder One

Kill 'Em All
Fav: Seek & Destroy
Least: Anesthesia doesn't really count, so Hit the Lights (it is perfect as the first song on their first album though)

Ride the Lightning
Fav: Fade to Black (Creeping Death #2)
Least: Escape, but it's still great

Master of Puppets
Fav: Welcome Home (Sanitarium), #2 is the title track
Least: Battery, but it's still great

And Justice For All
Fav: One, with Dyer's Eve at #2
Least: Shortest Straw, but it's still great

The Black Album
Fav: Wherever I May Roam
Least: Don't Tread On Me

Load
Fav: Thorn Within
Least: Poor Twisted Me

Reload
Fav: Unforgiven II by a wide margin
Least: Low Man's Lyric

St. Anger
Fav: The Unnamed Feeling
Least: My World

Death Magnetic
Fav: All Nightmare Long
Least: Unforgiven III (Would be a great song if they cut out some unneccesary parts)

Hardwired... to Self Destruct
Fav: Spit Out the Bone, duh
Least: ManUNKind

72 Seasons
Fav: Room of Mirrors (that solo)
Least: Lux AEterna (Still worked as a single though)

Not familiar enough with every Metallica album to answer this well, so I'll stick with the first three.

KEA
Fave: The Four Horsemen
Least: Anesthesia

RtL
Fave: Creeping Death
Least: Ktulu

MoP
Fave: Battery
Least: Damage Inc

Edit: if Anesthesia doesn't count, then I pick Jump in the Fire. That main riff just doesn't feel right to me.

StevenCressler wrote:Kill 'Em All
Fav: Seek & Destroy
Least: Anesthesia doesn't really count, so Hit the Lights (it is perfect as the first song on their first album though)

Ride the Lightning
Fav: Fade to Black (Creeping Death #2)
Least: Escape, but it's still great

Master of Puppets
Fav: Welcome Home (Sanitarium), #2 is the title track
Least: Battery, but it's still great

And Justice For All
Fav: One, with Dyer's Eve at #2
Least: Shortest Straw, but it's still great

The Black Album
Fav: Wherever I May Roam
Least: Don't Tread On Me

Load
Fav: Thorn Within
Least: Poor Twisted Me

Reload
Fav: Unforgiven II by a wide margin
Least: Low Man's Lyric

St. Anger
Fav: The Unnamed Feeling
Least: My World

Death Magnetic
Fav: All Nightmare Long
Least: Unforgiven III (Would be a great song if they cut out some unneccesary parts)

Hardwired... to Self Destruct
Fav: Spit Out the Bone, duh
Least: ManUNKind

72 Seasons
Fav: Room of Mirrors (that solo)
Least: Lux AEterna (Still worked as a single though)

How does Anesthesia not count? Also that's my second fav on the album.

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:Kill 'Em All
Fav: Seek & Destroy
Least: Anesthesia doesn't really count, so Hit the Lights (it is perfect as the first song on their first album though)

Ride the Lightning
Fav: Fade to Black (Creeping Death #2)
Least: Escape, but it's still great

Master of Puppets
Fav: Welcome Home (Sanitarium), #2 is the title track
Least: Battery, but it's still great

And Justice For All
Fav: One, with Dyer's Eve at #2
Least: Shortest Straw, but it's still great

The Black Album
Fav: Wherever I May Roam
Least: Don't Tread On Me

Load
Fav: Thorn Within
Least: Poor Twisted Me

Reload
Fav: Unforgiven II by a wide margin
Least: Low Man's Lyric

St. Anger
Fav: The Unnamed Feeling
Least: My World

Death Magnetic
Fav: All Nightmare Long
Least: Unforgiven III (Would be a great song if they cut out some unneccesary parts)

Hardwired... to Self Destruct
Fav: Spit Out the Bone, duh
Least: ManUNKind

72 Seasons
Fav: Room of Mirrors (that solo)
Least: Lux AEterna (Still worked as a single though)

How does Anesthesia not count? Also that's my second fav on the album.

Because it's just a bass solo. It's not really it's fault that it's my least favorite, because the only reason is there isn't much to it.