Rank the Deliverance Tourniquet and Metallica albums

I would have included Megadeth also but I haven't heard enough of their work to correctly place all their albums.
We see people rank these a lot, but now we can get them in context of other albums

[list=margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;padding-inline-start:48px;][*]And Justice for All 9.17
[*]Master of Puppets 9.15
[*]Assimilation 9.14
[*]Weapons of our Warfare 9.13
[*]Learn 8.96
[*]Microscopic View of a Telescopic Realm 8.95
[*]Deliverance 8.94
[*]Ride the Lightning 8.9125
[*]Stop the Bleeding 8.91
[*]What a Joke 8.85
[*]Psycho Surgery 8.84
[*]The Subversive Kind 8.825
[*]Antiseptic Bloodbath 8.8
[*]As Above - So Below 8.74
[*]Hear What I Say! 8.72
[*]Pathogenic Ocular Dissonance 8.7
[*]Death Magnetic 8.65
[*]Stay of Execution 8.64
[*]Metallica 8.58
[*]72 Seasons 8.54
[*]Where Moth and Rust Destroy 8.53
[*]Kill ‘Em All 8.53
[*]Vanishing Lessons 8.49
[*]Gazing at Medusa 8.48
[*]Hardwired… to Self-Destruct 8.36
[*]River Disturbance 8.3
[*]Crawl to China 8.28
[*]Camelot in Smithereens 8.13
[*]Reload 7.91
[*]Load 7.86
[*]St. Anger 7.27
[/list]

I can give you a bottom 3:
St. Anger
ReLoad 
Load

And a top 10:
AJfA
MoP
POD
WoOW
StB
PS
MVoaTR
WM&RD
RtL
SoE

Pethead wrote:I can give you a bottom 3:
St. Anger
ReLoad 
Load

And a top 10:
AJfA
MoP
POD
WoOW
StB
PS
MVoaTR
WM&RD
RtL
SoE

Pretty solid list

What A Joke over Pathogenic?  

What a joke.  

That's another server first achievement.

Do you laugh at that calamity?

Even if the filler was taken off, WaJ would still be lower-tier D. Which just goes to show how high their bar is.

But it's not even close to Pathogenic. Like, not in the same zip code.

I don’t think it’s in the same zip code as about 3/4 of TQT’s stuff.

Heck, make that 8/9.

Any Tourniquet album not called Vanishing Lessons or Crawl to China blows everything by Deliverance out of the water

seth wrote:Any Tourniquet album not called Vanishing Lessons or Crawl to China blows everything by Deliverance out of the water, except for Weapons and Stay. 

Fixed it for ya.

Superjuice wrote:What A Joke over Pathogenic?  

What a joke.  

That's another server first achievement.

I'll admit that my scores for Pathogenic are criminally low. I was half-asleep when I scored it. I'm sure it will beat WaJ when I redo it. (WaJ is still underrated though)

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:What A Joke over Pathogenic?  

What a joke.  

That's another server first achievement.

I'll admit that my scores for Pathogenic are criminally low. I was half-asleep when I scored it. I'm sure it will beat WaJ when I redo it. (WaJ is still underrated though)

Nah, just like what you like.

Don't just go along with what (seemingly) everyone else is saying or what they think is a band's best work.

Just be you.

Don't let the old codgers on this board bully you.






Since that's out of the way, 

WHAT ARE YOU THINKING PUTTING WHAT A FREAKIN JOKE AHEAD OF PATHOGENIC OCULAR DISSONANCE???!!!

You should never just follow the popular opinion.

You should follow the right opinion.

You should follow my opinion.

Superjuice wrote:What A Joke over Pathogenic?  

What a joke.  

That's another server first achievement.

Maybe he needs an actual Deliverance. 

Trust me, me wanting to change POD's ranking isn't me trying to conform to others opinions.
If that was the case I would be moving Assimilation down, and wouldn't have 72 Seasons above Kill 'Em All

Btw, here's my top 10 songs from these three
10. Weapons of our Warfare
9. Fade to Black
8. The Tomb of Gilgamesh
7. Master of Puppets
6. 1990
5. Dyer's Eve
4. Time
3. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
2. Broken Chromosomes
1. One

You need a Deliverance!

StevenCressler wrote:Btw, here's my top 10 songs from these three
10. Weapons of our Warfare
9. Fade to Black
8. The Tomb of Gilgamesh
7. Master of Puppets
6. 1990
5. Dyer's Eve
4. Time
3. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
2. Broken Chromosomes
1. One

I like the songs, but in a different order. 

Time and 1990 would be the last two!

TZ75 wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:Btw, here's my top 10 songs from these three
10. Weapons of our Warfare
9. Fade to Black
8. The Tomb of Gilgamesh
7. Master of Puppets
6. 1990
5. Dyer's Eve
4. Time
3. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
2. Broken Chromosomes
1. One

I like the songs, but in a different order. 

Time and 1990 would be the last two!

Learn is so underrated, but those two songs specially

Learn>What a Joke. I agree with your list on that point.

Learn is more serious adult oriented Metal. 

What A Joke is fast and furious youthful Metal.

Bottom 3:
10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001. Lulu
Crawl To China
Vanishing Lessons

Top 5:
5. TBA
4. WOOW
3. POD
2. MOP
1. ...AJFA

Also, TBA is much too low on your list. It's an S tier album. And either Load or ReLoad has to be higher. ReLoad has Metallica's worst song so it gets minus a few points so Load should be higher.

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:Also, TBA is much too low on your list. It's an S tier album. And either Load or ReLoad has to be higher. ReLoad has Metallica's worst song so it gets minus a few points so Load should be higher.

Black Album ain't S tier. It's got many great songs, but the albums above it are better. I have put Load higher now, I prefer it over ReLoad. Though Load has Metallica's worst song (Poor Twisted Me), Slither is very underrated.

StevenCressler wrote:

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:Also, TBA is much too low on your list. It's an S tier album. And either Load or ReLoad has to be higher. ReLoad has Metallica's worst song so it gets minus a few points so Load should be higher.

Black Album ain't S tier. It's got many great songs, but the albums above it are better. I have put Load higher now, I prefer it over ReLoad. Though Load has Metallica's worst song (Poor Twisted Me), Slither is very underrated.

Slither (especially the intro) is balls imo. I prefer all of St. Anger over it. Poor Twisted Me ain't bad.