Every Metallica song ranked

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:Wherever I May Roam over Shortest Straw?  Criminal.

Shortest Straw is a great song. But Wherever I May Roam has an amazing riff, one of their best imo.

I think it's stock!

Superjuice wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:Wherever I May Roam over Shortest Straw?  Criminal.

Shortest Straw is a great song. But Wherever I May Roam has an amazing riff, one of their best imo.

I think it's stock!

Idc, it sounds great. I rank songs based on how much I enjoy listening to them, not how much though went into making them.

Same, I love the riff of Sad but True, even though it’s really simple

seth wrote:Same, I love the riff of Sad but True, even though it’s really simple

Great example. That's one I always feel like moving down on my list when I think of how simple the riff is, but when I actually listen to it I remember how good it is despite that.

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:Wherever I May Roam over Shortest Straw?  Criminal.

Shortest Straw is a great song. But Wherever I May Roam has an amazing riff, one of their best imo.

I think it's stock!

Idc, it sounds great. I rank songs based on how much I enjoy listening to them, not how much though went into making them.

Never take a man seriously when he uses the word "stock" in a Metallica topic.

Superjuice wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:

Superjuice wrote:Wherever I May Roam over Shortest Straw?  Criminal.

Shortest Straw is a great song. But Wherever I May Roam has an amazing riff, one of their best imo.

I think it's stock!

Idc, it sounds great. I rank songs based on how much I enjoy listening to them, not how much though went into making them.

Never take a man seriously when he uses the word "stock" in a Metallica topic.

Isn't that a reference to the Some Kind Of Monster documentary or something?

It is.

StevenCressler wrote:Can someone get offended at one of my placings so we can get a discussion going

Am I Savage? and King Nothing are too low. As is Carpe Diem Baby, I love that song.

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

StevenCressler wrote:Can someone get offended at one of my placings so we can get a discussion going

Am I Savage? and King Nothing are too low. As is Carpe Diem Baby, I love that song.

I will be updating this soon. CDB and KN have already been updated and I still put them similarly. They're got, but far below par imo. And the breakdown is the only part that stands out in AIS?, the rest is just good.