Actors playing more than one superhero or supervillain

Awhile back, perhaps years ago, I started a thread cataloging actors who played more than one superhero or villain. I can't find the thread!

Oh well, starting again. Please list more as you find them. (I'll keep editing this post listing the ones you've provided in your comments.)

Ryan Reynolds
Green Lantern
Deadpool

Brandon Routh
Superman
Atom

Chris Evans
Human Torch
Captain America

Michael Keaton
Batman
Vulture

Ben Affleck
Batman
Daredevil

Halle Berry
Catwoman
Storm

Oooooh, a new one for the list:

Michael Keaton
Batman
Vulture

Birdman too, if you count that.

I didn't catch that movie. Wasn't even sure what it was about. (No spoilers please.)

Ben Affleck
Batman
Daredevil

Didn't Halle Barry play catwoman and another superhero?

New Creation wrote:I didn't catch that movie. Wasn't even sure what it was about. (No spoilers please.)

Eh it was ok.  It's about a washed-up actor who takes to live theater and his sorta mental breakdown.  The viewer isn't really sure what's real and what isn't (i.e. does he really have super powers?).  It won best picture, so by default you know it's going to be over-dramatized and pretentious, but it wasn't bad.  A decent rental I suppose.

If you add in animation, then Will Friedle has played Batman Beyond, Nightwing, and Blue Beetle. On that note, Frank Welker has played both the Marvel hero Iceman, and the DC villains Darkseid, Kalibak, and Joker. And if you consider the Transformers superheroes, we could throw Casey Kasem in there.

WildWorld wrote:If you add in animation, then Will Friedle has played Batman Beyond, Nightwing, and Blue Beetle. On that note, Frank Welker has played both the Marvel hero Iceman, and the DC villains Darkseid, Kalibak, and Joker. And if you consider the Transformers superheroes, we could throw Casey Kasem in there.

I think we should keep it to live action for now.

Staybrite wrote:Ben Affleck
Batman
Daredevil

Didn't Halle Barry play catwoman and another superhero?

Good addition.

And, you're right!

Halle Berry
Catwoman
Storm

New Creation wrote:

Staybrite wrote:Ben Affleck
Batman
Daredevil

Didn't Halle Barry play catwoman and another superhero?

Good addition.

And, you're right!

Halle Berry
Catwoman
Storm

Ah yes Storm.  I'm not a huge X-Men fan, so I'm not even sure I saw that film.  Thanks!

These arent as major comic characters (except The Punisher)

Nicole Kidman

was Dr. Chase Meridian in Batman Forever
is going to be Queen Atlanna, Aquaman's mother

Ray Stevenson

The Punisher
Volstagg (in Thor)

Staybrite wrote:

New Creation wrote:

Staybrite wrote:Ben Affleck
Batman
Daredevil

Didn't Halle Barry play catwoman and another superhero?

Good addition.

And, you're right!

Halle Berry
Catwoman
Storm

Ah yes Storm.  I'm not a huge X-Men fan, so I'm not even sure I saw that film.  Thanks!

The X-Men movies are really good.  Well, the third in each trilogy of films is the weakest link.  I highly recommend them.  Besides, if you throw in the Wolverine films, you only have 9 to catch up on.......for now.

Here's one you missed or didn't think about:


Uma Thurman
Poison Ivy in Batman & Robin (1997)
G-Girl in My Super Ex-Girlfriend (2006)

Will Smith
Hancock in Hancock (2006)
Deadshot in Suicide Squad (2016)

Can we count He-Man as a superhero? Because:

Dolph Lundgren
He-Man in Masters of the Universe (1987)
The Punisher in The Punisher (1989)

This next one is interesting:

Terrance Stamp
General Zod in Superman 2
Jor-El in Smallville (tv series)

This made me laugh today. We already discussed Chris Evans in this thread but now Michael B. Jordan fits the subject too. He'll be playing Erik Killmonger.

Old school:



Frank Gorshin as The Riddler


And Gomez... I mean John Astin as Riddler

And The Puzzler, which was supposed to be the Riddler. For some reason they changed the name to Puzzler but to me it is still The Riddler:


Maurice Evans as The Puzzler

And of course there were 3 Catwoman actress. Julie Newmar, Eartha Kitts, Lee Merriweather


And to me those first 2 pics look like Julie Newmar

MikeInFla wrote:Old school:

And The Puzzler, which was supposed to be the Riddler. For some reason they changed the name to Puzzler but to me it is still The Riddler

The Puzzler was actually not the Riddler, but a potential replacement for him (if the article below is to be believed). In the comics he was Superman's villain, not Batman's.

https://comicvine.gamespot.com/the-puzzler/4005-50106/

MikeInFla wrote:

And of course there were 3 Catwoman actress. Julie Newmar, Eartha Kitts, Lee Merriweather


And to me those first 2 pics look like Julie Newmar

That is Lee Meriweather in the middle, she looks incredibly similar to Newmar with the mask on

Newmar is still my all time favorite Catwoman

Yep, I know that heroes and villains have been played by multiple actors and actresses. I'm looking for actors and actresses who have played multiple heroes and/or villains.

Ryan Reynolds played Hannibal King in Blade Trinity.

I saw this on IMDB and thought of you, Adam. 

http://www.imdb.com/imdbpicks/comic-book-movie-stars/rg1219009280/?pf_rd_m=A2FGELUUNOQJNL&pf_rd_p=3155228022&pf_rd_r=0RPMWRSDN2APGPXSP88A&pf_rd_s=center-2&pf_rd_t=15061&pf_rd_i=homepage&ref_=hm_pks_cstars_sm

OK, so this one really stunned me.

We all know that Ben Affleck has now played Batman and Daredevil.

I will give 100 internet points to the first person here who can tell me what movie he played Superman in.

No, this is not a joke. Yes, Affleck actually played Superman in a movie (my wife and I watched it just last night) and yes, I will send you 100 internet points in a later post.

Aww... I know this one!  Haha you're tricky.  I saw it in theaters actually but I forget the title.  It's the one where he plays the actor who played Superman whose death was a bit of a mystery.

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0427969/?ref_=nm_flmg_act_22

Hollywoodland.