What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

by Black Rider Sat Dec 16, 2023 8:58 pm

Other than Roger of VR, Chris Boltendahl of Gravedigger ruins them for me. Otherwise I love the music.

by CrimsonWarrior Sat Dec 16, 2023 9:04 pm

Vengeance Rising and Ultimatum. I have not sampled every album, but all the vocals I heard were bad enough to ruin it for me.

Stop the Bleeding is listenable but sometimes hard for me to take seriously because the vocals are so bad. It is an inch away from being album-ruining.

by Seth Sat Dec 16, 2023 9:07 pm

Ultimatum is the right answer. I like their song One for All, but most of their stuff the vocals are really weird sounding, and not in a good way

by Pethead Sat Dec 16, 2023 9:12 pm

Ultimatum doesn't bother me. But for those it does, check out Into the Pit. Scott used a more guttural vocal on it and it works better.

Stop the Bleeding is great, although a couple of songs are borderline grating vocally (primarily Ready or Not).

Vengeance Rising comes very close to being ruined by the vocals, but I live with them.

by Seth Sat Dec 16, 2023 9:44 pm

Pethead wrote:Ultimatum doesn't bother me. But for those it does, check out Into the Pit. Scott used a more guttural vocal on it and it works better.

Stop the Bleeding is great, although a couple of songs are borderline grating vocally (primarily Ready or Not).

Vengeance Rising comes very close to being ruined by the vocals, but I live with them.

Yeah One for All is from that album, and he uses a pretty standard thrash voice there

by scottmitchell74 Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:14 pm

I like latter day Ultimatum - Into the Pit and following.

VR is fine.

Ritter is awesome!!

Can't think of any right now.

by Constantine Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:44 pm

Any metalcore band where the "singer" screams throughout the entire song.
I am not a masochist!

Any deathcore band that does that stupid pig squeal stuff.
Maybe do it for a song or two, but a whole album? Give me a break.

by Pethead Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:49 pm

That reminds me. A lot of the slam death metal vocals. So bad they’re comical.

by StevenCressler Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:52 pm

CrimsonWarrior wrote:Vengeance Rising and Ultimatum. I have not sampled every album, but all the vocals I heard were bad enough to ruin it for me.

Stop the Bleeding is listenable but sometimes hard for me to take seriously because the vocals are so bad. It is an inch away from being album-ruining.

tbh, I love the high-pitched vocals on StB

by Constantine Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:53 pm

StevenCressler wrote:

tbh, I love the high-pitched vocals on StB

Me too. They're like King Diamond without the Satanism!

by Pethead Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:55 pm

They work really well on The Threshing Floor.

by scottmitchell74 Sat Dec 16, 2023 10:56 pm

Whatever Archspire is; I like that.

by Seth Sat Dec 16, 2023 11:13 pm

Pethead wrote:That reminds me. A lot of the slam death metal vocals. So bad they’re comical.

Including “brutal” death metal for this question is basically cheating. The genre in which burping counts as vocals

by Seth Sat Dec 16, 2023 11:14 pm

And yeah Guy Ritter’s vocals are killer, they are a major part of why StB is so good

by WildWorld Sat Dec 16, 2023 11:50 pm

You're going to hate me, but Bloodgood. Something about those vocals just rubs me the wrong way.

by Pethead Sat Dec 16, 2023 11:56 pm

by Seth Sun Dec 17, 2023 12:00 am

I don’t hate Bloodgood’s vocals, but I can understand why some might not like them

by Raegoul Sun Dec 17, 2023 2:11 am

Overcome
ZAO
Strongarm on the second record (debut is perfect)

by Superjuice Sun Dec 17, 2023 8:31 am

WildWorld wrote:You're going to hate me, but Bloodgood. Something about those vocals just rubs me the wrong way.

I recall quite a few posters in the past that don't like him - not a big deal. Les Carlson is an acquired taste. I don't hate it, but really am not into it either. Dude's been at it forever though. He had a solo album in the early 70's. Respect.

For me:

Bride (see the Adam Sandler doing Axl Rose bit) and most extreme metal especially the wimpy clean vocals inherited from emo in metalcore.

by scottmitchell74 Sun Dec 17, 2023 8:50 am

Huh...

The above post just made me realize...

From about 1995-2022 the answer is...

Bride!!!

Dale Thompson - my all-time favorite vocalist...

Is the biggest reason I couldn't tolerate Bride on the stuff from Drop -through- Here is Your God.

The new one is good enough to buy... assessment TBD.

by Pethead Sun Dec 17, 2023 9:18 am

Some of y’all be needing this:

What's a band that the vocals kill it for you? Img_1511

by Pethead Sun Dec 17, 2023 9:30 am

A couple for me:

Divine Retribution—the vocalist has a nice voice, but the vocals are off-key quite a bit on the album.

Guardian: First Watch—this doesn’t quite ruin the album since the vocals are on key, but I’ve always found Paul’s vocals too weak for the music, especially compared to Jamie.

Living Sacrifice: Nonexistent—if the vocals were more locked into the music and a bit more intelligible, it’d be fine. But as it is the vocals make it hard to enjoy the album.

by Seth Sun Dec 17, 2023 11:21 am

Dale Thompson is a interesting case. On some albums his vocals are some of the best I’ve ever heard, on others he sounds like a knockoff Axl Rose

by alldatndensum Sun Dec 17, 2023 12:12 pm

For me, when they do the extreme or core vocals that are growling, screetching, or pig squealing. I am out at that point. I can handle those techniques if they are used sporadically to emphasize a phrase to add power and have even used growling on a couple of instances myself for this purpose. But, if that is all, or mostly, what you bring to the table, I ain't eatin' at that table. I will find something with more melodic vocals.

by Pethead Sun Dec 17, 2023 1:40 pm

Hansi from Blind Guardian almost ruins them for me, but I still like the band.

by Sponsored content

What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?

Re: What's a band that the vocals kill it for you?