Re: Rank the Big 4

by Black Rider Sat Jun 10, 2023 9:41 pm

That's a cry for help, right?

by Pethead Sat Jun 10, 2023 9:48 pm

Black Rider wrote:That's a cry for help, right?

I dunno; it might honestly be too late.

by Son of Nun Sat Jun 10, 2023 10:50 pm

Airola wrote:Here's a complete list, minus the newest albums by Megadeth and Metallica.
I went through every album, ranking each song 0-5, and counting the average gave the final score for each album (again 0-5).

01. MEGADETH: Peace Sells... But Who's Buying? | (1986) | 4,13
02. MEGADETH: Rust in Peace | (1990) | 4,11
03. METALLICA: Master of Puppets | (1986) | 4,06
04. MEGADETH: Killing Is My Business... And Business Is Good! | (1985) | 3,94
05. MEGADETH: Endgame | (2009) | 3,91
06. ANTHRAX: Among the Living | (1987) | 3,89
07. ANTHRAX: Fistful of Metal | (1984) | 3,85
08. ANTHRAX: Spreading the Disease | (1985) | 3,83
09. SLAYER: Seasons in the Abyss | (1990) | 3,80
10. METALLICA: Ride the Lightning | (1984) | 3,75
11. MEGADETH: The System Has Failed | (2004) | 3,67
12. MEGADETH: So Far, So Good... So What! | (1988) | 3,63
13. SLAYER: Divine Intervention | (1994) | 3,45
14. METALLICA: ...And Justice for All | (1988) | 3,39
15. METALLICA: St. Anger | (2003) | 3,32
16. MEGADETH: Youthanasia | (1994) | 3,29
17. METALLICA: Metallica | (1991) | 3,29
18. MEGADETH: Dystopia | (2016) | 3,27
19. SLAYER: Reign in Blood | (1986) | 3,25
20. MEGADETH: Cryptic Writings | (1997) | 3,25
21. MEGADETH: The World Needs a Hero | (2001) | 3,21
22. ANTHRAX: Worship Music | (2011) | 3,21
23. METALLICA: Death Magnetic | (2008) | 3,20
24. ANTHRAX: For All Kings | (2016) | 3,18
25. SLAYER: South of Heaven | (1988) | 3,10
26. SLAYER: Hell Awaits | (1985) | 3,07
27. ANTHRAX: Sound of White Noise | (1993) | 2,91
28. MEGADETH: Countdown to Extinction | (1992) | 2,91
29. METALLICA: Kill 'Em All | (1983) | 2,90
30. MEGADETH: United Abominations | (2007) | 2,86
31. MEGADETH: Risk | (1999) | 2,83
32. MEGADETH: Thirteen | (2011) | 2,81
33. METALLICA: Reload | (1997) | 2,81
34. SLAYER: Show No Mercy | (1983) | 2,80
35. SLAYER: Christ Illusion | (2006) | 2,80
36. ANTHRAX: Persistence of Time | (1990) | 2,78
37. ANTHRAX: State of Euphoria | (1988) | 2,75
38. SLAYER: World Painted Blood | (2009) | 2,73
39. MEGADETH: Super Collider | (2013) | 2,68
40. METALLICA: Load | (1996) | 2,68
41. METALLICA: Hardwired... to Self-Destruct | (2016) | 2,67
42. SLAYER: Diabolus in Musica | (1998) | 2,60
43. SLAYER: Repentless | (2015) | 2,58
44. SLAYER: God Hates Us All | (2001) | 2,54
45. ANTHRAX: We've Come for You All | (2003) | 2,50
46. ANTHRAX: Volume 8: The Threat Is Real | (1998) | 2,47
47. SLAYER: Undisputed Attitude | (1996) | 2,36
48. ANTHRAX: Stomp 442 | (1995) | 2,18

And here's the final score for each of the bands:
1. Megadeth: 3,37
2. Metallica: 3,21
3. Anthrax: 3,05
4. Slayer: 2,93

This is great. Exactly the kind of thing I try to do on Rate Your Music. It just takes me forever haha.

by ReedBenson Sun Jun 11, 2023 8:03 am

Metallica - Death Magnetic
Megadeth - The System Has Failed
Slayer - (never listened to a full album)
Anthrax - (same)

by Pethead Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:16 pm

If anyone is bored:

https://loudwire.com/every-big-4-thrash-metal-album-ranked/

Obviously, I have sharp disagreements. And I’m sure Kerrick will object that the top 10 isn’t all Slayer albums.

by mothy Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:26 pm

^^oh yeah I have a lot of disagreements with this list.

by Pethead Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:27 pm

Someone who can honestly say Super Collider is the worst thing by any of the big 4 is clearly not using their ears or their critical thinking.

by mothy Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:29 pm

Amen, and they knock it for being a rock album but have Risk lower on the list....huh?

by Black Rider Fri Jul 28, 2023 8:49 pm

Hahahahahahaha.
He really doesn't like Megadeth for the most part.

by StevenCressler Mon Mar 04, 2024 11:07 pm

Pethead wrote:Side note: other than Fabulous Disaster, I’ve never been able to get into Exodus. I don’t jive with their riffing style, and their lyrics are often just as moronic as Slayer’s.

Aren't their lyrics worse? I don't know what Slayer's worse songs are, but I don't think they have any songs like "Liar Lunatic Lord"... or do they? Idk.

by StevenCressler Mon Mar 04, 2024 11:09 pm

mothy wrote:^^Sorry but that comment gets my first ever "dislike"

I guess you took it off

by Pethead Mon Mar 04, 2024 11:10 pm

StevenCressler wrote:
Pethead wrote:Side note: other than Fabulous Disaster, I’ve never been able to get into Exodus. I don’t jive with their riffing style, and their lyrics are often just as moronic as Slayer’s.
Aren't their lyrics worse? I don't know what Slayer's worse songs are, but I don't think they have any songs like "Liar Lunatic Lord"... or do they? Idk.

Slayer has an entire album called Christ Illusion.

by StevenCressler Mon Mar 04, 2024 11:12 pm

Pethead wrote:
StevenCressler wrote:
Pethead wrote:Side note: other than Fabulous Disaster, I’ve never been able to get into Exodus. I don’t jive with their riffing style, and their lyrics are often just as moronic as Slayer’s.
Aren't their lyrics worse? I don't know what Slayer's worse songs are, but I don't think they have any songs like "Liar Lunatic Lord"... or do they? Idk.
Slayer has an entire album called Christ Illusion.

That's true... forgot about that lol. Wonder how Tom justified singing that to himself...

by StevenCressler Mon Mar 04, 2024 11:18 pm

4. Slayer - Seasoning the Obese
3. Anthrax - Among the Living
2. Megaseth - Rusty Peas
1. Metallica - And Justice For All

I prefer Slayer over Anthrax musically, but...

by Christian Thrash Rules Tue Mar 05, 2024 11:12 am

I never cared much for Slayer or Anthrax but here we go.

1. Metallica
I know that some people think they're overrated, but are they actually overrated or are you just tired of them? They wouldn't be as popular as they are if they didn't deserve it.
...AJFA/MOP

2. Megadeth
This band is awesome. Also Dave is now Christian which is awesome.
RIP/CTE

3. Anthrax
I never listened to them much but I love Safe Home.
None

4. Slayer
The singer/bassist my be Catholic but he writes the worst lyrics... except for Cannible Corpse, Mayhem and Ghost I guess.
Reign In Blood

by Christian Thrash Rules Tue Mar 05, 2024 11:13 am

StevenCressler wrote:
Pethead wrote:
StevenCressler wrote:
Pethead wrote:Side note: other than Fabulous Disaster, I’ve never been able to get into Exodus. I don’t jive with their riffing style, and their lyrics are often just as moronic as Slayer’s.
Aren't their lyrics worse? I don't know what Slayer's worse songs are, but I don't think they have any songs like "Liar Lunatic Lord"... or do they? Idk.
Slayer has an entire album called Christ Illusion.
That's true... forgot about that lol. Wonder how Tom justified singing that to himself...

They also have a song called "God Hates Us All". If I remember correctly he was asked about it and his response was "Well I don't actually mean it."

by Pethead Tue Mar 05, 2024 11:54 am

If you guys haven’t been impressed with Anthrax I strongly recommend checking out Spreading the Disease and Persistence of Time. Those are my favorites. Spreading is very melodic and lighthearted (for thrash), while Persistence is much darker and heavier.

by StevenCressler Tue Mar 05, 2024 1:46 pm

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:I never cared much for Slayer or Anthrax but here we go.

1. Metallica
I know that some people think they're overrated, but are they actually overrated or are you just tired of them? They wouldn't be as popular as they are if they didn't deserve it.
...AJFA/MOP

2. Megadeth
This band is awesome. Also Dave is now Christian which is awesome.
RIP/CTE

3. Anthrax
I never listened to them much but I love Safe Home.
None

4. Slayer
The singer/bassist my be Catholic but he writes the worst lyrics... except for Cannible Corpse, Mayhem and Ghost I guess.
Reign In Blood

Tom doesn't write most of Slayer's lyrics. Kerry is the one who usually writes the awful blasphemous junk the band is known for

by StevenCressler Tue Mar 05, 2024 1:49 pm

Pethead wrote:If you guys haven’t been impressed with Anthrax I strongly recommend checking out Spreading the Disease and Persistence of Time. Those are my favorites. Spreading is very melodic and lighthearted (for thrash), while Persistence is much darker and heavier.

I like Anthrax. I just prefer the two that start with Me and have some association with Mustains. Among the Living has one of my all-time favorite guitar tones.

Later I might try to rank all the albums even though I only know about half of them.

by Sponsored content