Metallica Black Album, Heavy Metal or Heavy Rock?

Dustofyears wrote:You took this out of context. When you know what the you're talking about come back and we'll chat, otherwise— learn more, talk less.

Samson wrote:Doesn't matter. It's awesome

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

Dustofyears wrote:You took this out of context. When you know what the you're talking about come back and we'll chat, otherwise— learn more, talk less.

What do you mean? I do know what I'm talking about. You said TBA is rock and I know it's metal.

Dustofyears wrote:Read the original. and the original post it's all there. Of course it's heavy metal, it's got thrash in it.  The base of the album is heavy rock! All those bands, like Die Happy, TQT and Deliverance stopped thrash and played heavy rock because of that album. Yes they still have heavy metal in it because if the thrash elements"... Now go listen to that Alice in chains video I posted, which is Heavy Rock, add some thrash elements to that sound...now does the black album sound closer to that or Judas Priest. It's all there IN context.

Dustofyears wrote:I mean to begin with you were calling Count down to Extinction a thrash album lolz.

Dustofyears wrote:Did you listen to Alice and chains song... that is heavy rock. Now listen to the Metallica song after it. Yes it's still Metal, but the base of the album is Heavy rock. Just listen to the songs, it's right there for you to hear.

How the heck I allow myself to get into this lolz. Listen if you want to learn. Don't if you don't.


Count down to extinction is not a thrash metal album. May as well say load is a thrash metal album too because Metallica wrote it...ok I'm done. Count Down to extinction is thrash/rock album like TBA. Cheers.

Christian Thrash Rules wrote:

Dustofyears wrote:Read the original. and the original post it's all there. Of course it's heavy metal, it's got thrash in it.  The base of the album is heavy rock! All those bands, like Die Happy, TQT and Deliverance stopped thrash and played heavy rock because of that album. Yes they still have heavy metal in it because if the thrash elements"... Now go listen to that Alice in chains video I posted, which is Heavy Rock, add some thrash elements to that sound...now does the black album sound closer to that or Judas Priest. It's all there IN context.

I'm not saying Heavy Rock isn't a thing. TBA is most def not rock. Heavy Metal is a broad sub-genre. Also JP is traditional metal not heavy. For it to be rock, it can't be metal, which it very much is.

Superjuice wrote:It's Bob Rock Metal